How I Got Revenge on My Mother-in-Law with a Fake House Key

6 months ago

Managing relationships, especially with in-laws, can feel like balancing on a thin wire without any backup. This reader tried to use some jokes to establish limits, but things went in a different direction. Let’s explore these complicated family dynamics together!

Yes, that was more than acceptable. Y'all should get a security system installed. That'd really straighten her out


Thank you for sharing your dilemma with us. You have asked us to weigh in on your decision to expose your mother-in-law by giving her a fake key to your house. You have also asked us if this was an acceptable way to teach her a lesson about personal boundaries, or if you went too far.

We understand your frustration and anger at your mother-in-law’s intrusive and disrespectful behavior. It is not easy to deal with someone who constantly snoops around your house, goes through your personal belongings, and rearranges your furniture. It is even harder to cope with someone who ignores your requests to stop and insists on having an emergency key to your house.

However, we also believe that your solution was not the best one. While it may have given you a temporary sense of satisfaction and justice, it also created more problems and conflicts within your family. By giving your mother-in-law a fake key, you essentially lied to her and set her up for humiliation. You also risked damaging your relationship with your husband, who may have felt betrayed by your actions.

We think that there are better ways to deal with a meddling mother-in-law than resorting to deception and revenge. Here are some suggestions that may help you in the future:

  • Communicate clearly and firmly. Instead of giving your mother-in-law a fake key, you could have told her that you do not want her to have a key to your house at all. You could have explained to her that you value your privacy and autonomy, and that you expect her to respect your boundaries. You could have also asked her to call or text you before visiting, and to limit her visits to certain times and occasions.
  • Set consequences and enforce them. If your mother-in-law continues to violate your boundaries, you could have taken some actions to show her that you are serious. For example, you could have changed the locks on your doors, installed a security system, or even filed a restraining order. You could have also reduced or cut off contact with her until she apologizes and changes her behavior.
  • Seek support and mediation. If your mother-in-law is unwilling to listen or compromise, you could have sought the help of other family members, friends, or professionals. You could have asked your husband to talk to his mother and make her understand your point of view. You could have also invited a neutral third party, such as a counselor or a mediator, to facilitate a constructive dialogue between you and your mother-in-law.
  • Focus on the positive and be compassionate. While it may be hard to find anything good about your mother-in-law, you could have tried to focus on the positive aspects of your relationship with her. You could have acknowledged that she is your husband’s mother, and that she may have some good qualities or intentions. You could have also tried to understand her perspective and motivations, and to empathize with her feelings and needs.

We hope that these suggestions will help you to deal with your mother-in-law in a more effective and respectful way. We also hope that you will be able to resolve your conflict and restore harmony in your family. Remember that you are not alone in this situation, and that there are many resources and people who can support you.

While the decoy key unveiled a mother-in-law’s intrusive tendencies, a new email quietly arrived in our editorial inbox, carrying the weight of someone else’s mother-in-law’s struggles. Check out our next article featuring how she wants to be treated like a wife.


Get notifications
Lucky you! This thread is empty,
which means you've got dibs on the first comment.
Go for it!

Related Reads