I Refuse to Let My Husband’s Child Move In — Now He’s Threatening Me with Divorce

Jodie, 37, has written us a heartfelt and emotional letter, expressing her concerns about her family situation. She seeks genuine opinions from our readers regarding her decision not to allow her husband’s 8-year-old daughter to live with them permanently. Jodie feels that her reasons for this decision are valid, but her husband is upset about her reluctance to share their home with his child. Let’s delve into the details of this complex family dynamic.

Jodie and her husband Mike are both happy in their second marriage.

Jodie, 37, is a successful woman who has achieved a lot in her career, rising from a nurse to the chief doctor of cardiology. She enjoys a fulfilling job and a happy marriage with her husband, Mike. However, she’s facing a significant challenge in her new family dynamic that is affecting her well-being.

The woman has shared her family story and the tough decision she made, which has led to ongoing conflicts and misunderstandings with her husband, Mike. She is seeking our readers’ opinions on this contentious issue and hopes to receive insightful advice from those who may have faced similar situations.

Jodie opened her letter, saying, “I’ve been married to my husband Mike for over 3 years now. This is my second marriage, and the same is for Mike. We’re quite happy in our relationship, because it’s mature, stable and transparent. We both have been working hard on achieving that level of mutual understanding and trust that we now have in our family. Everything seemed good so far, but there’s a problem that doesn’t allow us to move forward with our happy marriage. And this problem is Mike’s expectations from me towards his child, Kylie.”

Mike has a daughter from a previous marriage, and Jodie has consistently been kind to her.

Jodie disclosed, “Mike has a child from his previous marriage. His daughter Kylie is 8. Mike was open about the child from the beginning of our relationship. He has Kylie every two weeks on weekends. I’ve always told him that’s fine, I have absolutely no problem with it. I believe he can spend time with her as much as he wants, and I won’t make a fuss about it. If he wanted to include me, I would always happily join on activities as well.”

She added, “But I also made it clear to my husband that I’m not Kylie’s parent, that’s him and his ex. Of course, I would look after the girl if she was left with me, I never ignored her. I cooked too when she was with us, and if she wanted to talk or play with me, I’d do that too. But I refuse to parent her. I was clear about that. If Kylie did something that required grounding, for example, I would not be the one to tell her and ground or punish her. That’s a parent’s duty, which I am not.”

The family situation suddenly became tense.

Jodie shared, "10 months ago Mike lost his job and since he couldn’t find a new one fast enough, he got evicted from the apartment he had been living in before we moved in together. He kept that apartment even after our marriage, and we both thought that was fine. I have my own house, and I live in it, Mike lived in that apartment and worked from there, this was the model of marriage we had agreed on, and we did find it convenient. But since he lost that apartment, I told him he can move in with me.

“I got a spare room, which I turned into a bedroom for Kylie, so she has a comfortable place to stay when she’s with us. Things went totally fine the whole time, just last week Mike sat me down for a serious talk. He told me that his ex-wife found out about his new living situation and since she’s living in an apartment, she told Mike it would be way better if Kylie lives full time with us and visits her twice a month.”

Jodie was stunned when she received the news. She confessed, “I was absolutely furious, and I’m sure you can understand why. My husband made the decision without discussing it with me first and then presented it as, ’Honey, please be happy! Our little girl will be living with us full time now.’ I laughed, thinking he was joking.”

Jodie is frustrated by her husband’s wish and has openly expressed her concerns.

Jodie shared, “Unfortunately, Mike wasn’t joking at all. I immediately told him I wasn’t okay with it, not at all. Even though I don’t work from home, I never wanted kids, and that hasn’t changed. Mike had been fine with this arrangement before.”

“My husband tried to guilt-trip me, saying it wasn’t right for Kylie to live in an apartment and that he just wanted to provide her with a better living situation. I reminded him that this is my house, not his, and it’s my decision who lives here permanently — especially not behind my back. Mike got angry and accused me of emasculating him and demanded an apology. I quickly got up, packed his suitcase, and told him to get his things and move out. He said he would file for divorce.”

Jodie added, “After Mike left, his ex started blowing up my phone. She keeps telling me what an evil person I am to take stability from Kylie, and called me a monster. I told her that she’s the mother and providing stability is her burden, not mine. Though I feel like my decision was justified, I still feel guilty about Kylie in this situation. What should I do?”

Jodie was undoubtedly facing an extremely challenging situation. In our opinion, it was certainly wrong of Mike to require her to become a parent to someone else’s child, especially when she had clearly stated from the beginning that she wasn’t ready for it. Jodie has every right to protect her personal boundaries.

What would you do if you were in Jodie’s position? Would you be willing to set aside your reluctance to have children to save your marriage? Share your thoughts in the comments section.

And here’s a story about a woman whose new boyfriend insisted on spending time alone with her son, and a hidden camera uncovered a shocking truth.